No, to new TV show or movie!

For discussions about the long-rumored MPI movie

Moderator: Styles Bitchley

Message
Author
User avatar
MagnumILWU
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 629
Joined: Mon Mar 12, 2012 5:44 pm
Location: Portland Oregon

No, to new TV show or movie!

#1 Post by MagnumILWU »

I, for one, do not like the idea of a new Magnum, PI TV show or movie! I watched the show from the beginning. And re-runs hundreds of times! I have a couple of VHS tapes from original broadcasts on CBS! The show cannot be copied or replaced! I believe anything would be a disappointment, and not stand-up to the original! Tom Selleck is Thomas Magnum, John Hillerman is Jonathan Quayle Higgins III, Larry Manetti is Rick Wright, and Roger E Mosley is TC! They cannot be replaced! Poor Agatha and Mac are gone! Lt Tanaka, Ice Pick, Carol Baldwin, this is my Magnum,PI, and there is no way to improve it, or do it again! It was/is a once in a lifetime experience, that I will always treasure!
"pickled egg please"

Seaver41
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 388
Joined: Mon Dec 01, 2008 4:46 pm

Re: No, to new TV show or movie!

#2 Post by Seaver41 »

MagnumILWU wrote:I, for one, do not like the idea of a new Magnum, PI TV show or movie! I watched the show from the beginning. And re-runs hundreds of times! I have a couple of VHS tapes from original broadcasts on CBS! The show cannot be copied or replaced! I believe anything would be a disappointment, and not stand-up to the original! Tom Selleck is Thomas Magnum, John Hillerman is Jonathan Quayle Higgins III, Larry Manetti is Rick Wright, and Roger E Mosley is TC! They cannot be replaced! Poor Agatha and Mac are gone! Lt Tanaka, Ice Pick, Carol Baldwin, this is my Magnum,PI, and there is no way to improve it, or do it again! It was/is a once in a lifetime experience, that I will always treasure!
when I came to the site I was all gung ho about getting as movie done with original cast only. I've now come to the realization that it can never be the same or as good as it once was......nor would it be given the kind of treatment needed to be a success. This I've accepted. Bottom line is the demogrpahics aren't there to pull it off. A good chunk of Magnum's crowd is gone and what is left is simply not enough for a movie studio to back a tv cast. It's just not a good gamble.

The only chance is to get it done is an A-list actor to carry the torch forward and somehow incorporate Selleck....but even that is thin. Sadly, the best chance of a Magnum movie happening is after Selleck is gone or incapable of reprising the role...........then maybe at that point the nostalgia for Magnum might get a movie done.........but we know it will never capture the magic of the original.

Buck
Captain
Posts: 74
Joined: Sun Jun 07, 2009 7:15 pm

Re: No, to new TV show or movie!

#3 Post by Buck »

Seaver41 wrote:
MagnumILWU wrote:I, for one, do not like the idea of a new Magnum, PI TV show or movie! I watched the show from the beginning. And re-runs hundreds of times! I have a couple of VHS tapes from original broadcasts on CBS! The show cannot be copied or replaced! I believe anything would be a disappointment, and not stand-up to the original! Tom Selleck is Thomas Magnum, John Hillerman is Jonathan Quayle Higgins III, Larry Manetti is Rick Wright, and Roger E Mosley is TC! They cannot be replaced! Poor Agatha and Mac are gone! Lt Tanaka, Ice Pick, Carol Baldwin, this is my Magnum,PI, and there is no way to improve it, or do it again! It was/is a once in a lifetime experience, that I will always treasure!
when I came to the site I was all gung ho about getting as movie done with original cast only. I've now come to the realization that it can never be the same or as good as it once was......nor would it be given the kind of treatment needed to be a success. This I've accepted. Bottom line is the demogrpahics aren't there to pull it off. A good chunk of Magnum's crowd is gone and what is left is simply not enough for a movie studio to back a tv cast. It's just not a good gamble.

The only chance is to get it done is an A-list actor to carry the torch forward and somehow incorporate Selleck....but even that is thin. Sadly, the best chance of a Magnum movie happening is after Selleck is gone or incapable of reprising the role...........then maybe at that point the nostalgia for Magnum might get a movie done.........but we know it will never capture the magic of the original.
I think there is enough interest in the original cast to make a movie or miniseries profitable.

Tom Selleck draws large viewership numbers for Jessie Stone movies and Blue Bloods. There is no reason to think Tom Selleck would not draw even larger numbers for the role that made him famous. If you want to get more younger viewers, pick any 18-25 year old female model or pop star from American Idol/Bachelor to be a guest star, and then put her in a bikini on the beach in Hawaii. A bimbo does not need to be a great actress to get the job done!

I doubt any new actors could satisfy Magnum fans who watched the show when it originally aired on TV.

Braddah Kimo
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 456
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2011 8:48 pm
Location: Hawaii

#4 Post by Braddah Kimo »

I foresee a Magnum PI movie along the lines of the Husky and Starch movie. A slight nod to the original, but with box office star power in place, set in Hawai'i of course... The demographics will always be there.
Plus, seems as if the studios are going down the list of old TV shows to make into moviehouse fare. Seems inevitable.
I for one am neither for nor against it. Because it is not my choice nor do I invest or produce or otherwise have any say in the greenlighting of such a project. But just as with the H50 redux series, I am all for anything that gives kama'aina more work. And a movie production would do this.

And if Ms. Andersen prefers not to allow her estate available for the setting, I nominate the Clarence H. Cooke/Marks' estate.

St Max Kolbe
Lieutenant Junior Grade
Posts: 14
Joined: Wed Oct 17, 2012 3:03 pm
Location: Australia

Re: No, to new TV show or movie!

#5 Post by St Max Kolbe »

MagnumILWU wrote:I, for one, do not like the idea of a new Magnum, PI TV show or movie! I watched the show from the beginning. And re-runs hundreds of times! I have a couple of VHS tapes from original broadcasts on CBS! The show cannot be copied or replaced! I believe anything would be a disappointment, and not stand-up to the original! Tom Selleck is Thomas Magnum, John Hillerman is Jonathan Quayle Higgins III, Larry Manetti is Rick Wright, and Roger E Mosley is TC! They cannot be replaced! Poor Agatha and Mac are gone! Lt Tanaka, Ice Pick, Carol Baldwin, this is my Magnum,PI, and there is no way to improve it, or do it again! It was/is a once in a lifetime experience, that I will always treasure!
I agree, when I heard of Matthew McConaughey being touted as the next TM I decided I wouldnt watch it, ditto with Macy as Higgins. Then I thought no-one could do TM because as you say TS is TM or maybe its vice versa. Anyone else trying to be like Sellect won't work. Likewise with someone trying to do a completely different TM, it will no longer be what made it, and most likely highly degenerative. Selleck was so unique in that role and I get the feeling he was almost being himself thats why it all came so naturally. I could see producers desiring a new TM being like the typical post millenium character - someone who looks rough, is brutal with females, a pseudo hard man.
St Damien of Molokai - Ora pro nobis!

Seaver41
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 388
Joined: Mon Dec 01, 2008 4:46 pm

#6 Post by Seaver41 »

I've always thought Gerard Butler could pull ioff the intended role of lighthearted comedy with action...........he's certainly tough enough (300) and has played light comedy roles as well.

Doesn't matter...........any remake will fail like the Miami Vice movie. Borrowing the names and places doesn't make Magnum.

User avatar
JT
Captain
Posts: 72
Joined: Sat May 01, 2010 11:40 am
Location: The Netherlands

#7 Post by JT »

Totally agree with you Seaver. Man Miami Vice was a BAD movie. The same goes for the A team movie. I hope they never screw up Magnum!

User avatar
Doc Ibold
Maniac Emeritus
Posts: 1741
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2007 8:16 pm
Location: Detroit

#8 Post by Doc Ibold »

If you're going to do it, it would have to be with Lily and the brood of the guys. Cameos from the original cast. I actually have a decent idea of how it would play out in my head.

You can't do Magnum as it was, and cannot replace the characters, but you can recapture the spirit.

lanceroten
Lieutenant Junior Grade
Posts: 7
Joined: Wed Dec 15, 2010 8:54 pm

#9 Post by lanceroten »

Doc Ibold wrote:If you're going to do it, it would have to be with Lily and the brood of the guys. Cameos from the original cast. I actually have a decent idea of how it would play out in my head.

You can't do Magnum as it was, and cannot replace the characters, but you can recapture the spirit.

I agree. I believe if the right person took on this project, the spirit of the series would carry it. Nobody in the cast is a kid anymore :D . But I shudder to think what Hollywood would do if they replaced a Selleck in the Magnum role. He has to be there in some way, shape or form.

User avatar
ConchRepublican
COZITV Magnum, P.I. SuperFan / Chief Barkeep - Flemingo Key
Posts: 2999
Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 6:19 pm
Location: Flemingo Key
Contact:

#10 Post by ConchRepublican »

Doc Ibold wrote:If you're going to do it, it would have to be with Lily and the brood of the guys. Cameos from the original cast. I actually have a decent idea of how it would play out in my head.

You can't do Magnum as it was, and cannot replace the characters, but you can recapture the spirit.
I still think this is one of the best ideas.
CoziTV Superfan spot
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPTmsykLQ04

User avatar
Estate resident
Captain
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Apr 27, 2009 9:47 pm

Re: No, to new TV show or movie!

#11 Post by Estate resident »

If, repeat, IF it was done right it could work and be a helluva hit. I never would have believed the Indiana Jones comeback movie would have worked but Spielberg & Ford pulled it off. Selleck & Bellasario could easily do the same thing. Magnum, Rick, TC, and even Higgins are all still alive & capable of shooting a feature film. Its a goldmine waiting to be dug up & cashed in from a financial perspective. In Selleck's words it would be interesting to see what MPI has been up to. CBS's reviving of Hawaii Five'O is proof enough. I am sure this idea has been discussed at numerous executive board meetings. MPI fan base (as this board proves daily) is probably the most loyal in existence. There was a petition somewhere on the internet to bring MPI back & again I'm sure it was viewed by the people in power.

If they're going to do it they better get on the stick & soon. Then again maybe they're waiting for the original cast to be too old to do it again. Who knows why it hasn't been done. Until then at least we all have Netflix & dvd's.

> http://www.nbcbayarea.com/blogs/popcorn ... 40803.html

User avatar
golfmobile
Chopper Pilot Wannabe
Posts: 1203
Joined: Fri Apr 06, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Atlanta area
Contact:

Re: No, to new TV show or movie!

#12 Post by golfmobile »

This comment will probably bring great support or great antagonism. Having just seen "The Lone Ranger":

If there were a way to do it with Armie Hammer as Magnum and Johnny Depp as -- are you ready? I think he would actually make a HYSTERICAL Higgins! But it would take some REALLY GOOD writing! If someone could get Johnny Depp on board, I bet it could be done, and it would be entertaining. Not a repeat of the original -- that simply doesn't exist except on celluloid and in our hearts, minds, and DVD players. But a new one? The only one I would go see. Well, actually, I'd go see anything that was done, whether I liked it or not, just to see HOW it worked (or not). But still, I vote for a Johnny Depp vehicle.

JMO

golf
"Portside, buddy."

Braddah Kimo
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 456
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2011 8:48 pm
Location: Hawaii

Re: No, to new TV show or movie!

#13 Post by Braddah Kimo »

excellent idea, actually!
I can see it now
"Me wantum YOU off my beach. Now. beach private! I no go on YOUR reservation! You stay. off mine."
wait. wrong accent.
Still Depp can do it, I think he did a british thang in some film a while back. That peter pan thing?

Braddah Kimo
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 456
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2011 8:48 pm
Location: Hawaii

Re: No, to new TV show or movie!

#14 Post by Braddah Kimo »

Just sent an email to Bruckheimer positing that idea...

ohmygod
Lieutenant Junior Grade
Posts: 9
Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2014 12:34 am

Re: No, to new TV show or movie!

#15 Post by ohmygod »

Estate resident wrote:If, repeat, IF it was done right it could work and be a helluva hit. I never would have believed the Indiana Jones comeback movie would have worked but Spielberg & Ford pulled it off. Selleck & Bellasario could easily do the same thing. Magnum, Rick, TC, and even Higgins are all still alive & capable of shooting a feature film. Its a goldmine waiting to be dug up & cashed in from a financial perspective. In Selleck's words it would be interesting to see what MPI has been up to. CBS's reviving of Hawaii Five'O is proof enough. I am sure this idea has been discussed at numerous executive board meetings. MPI fan base (as this board proves daily) is probably the most loyal in existence. There was a petition somewhere on the internet to bring MPI back & again I'm sure it was viewed by the people in power.

If they're going to do it they better get on the stick & soon. Then again maybe they're waiting for the original cast to be too old to do it again. Who knows why it hasn't been done. Until then at least we all have Netflix & dvd's.

> http://www.nbcbayarea.com/blogs/popcorn ... 40803.html
I too agree that it's all in the writing but also directing, and about the Five O revival as proof of concept. But I don't think it should be a movie, just like Five O was not made into a movie. Indiana Jones revival is another good point, but also it always was a movie. They made an indiana series as young indiana but it failed after the first year. I think some things should be movies and some should be on tv, and IMO MPI as a movie it would be too easy for it to skew away from the spirit of the original show, even if from the start this wasn't the intent. It may attract some newer audiences but that's the problem, old school fans will not be that pleased. They rebooted Star Trek (original) for example in 2009. While it was pretty good initial effort, the 2nd film (Star Trek into darkness) failed IMO (and a lot of fans feel that too), and they probably didn't set out with the intent to alienate old school star trek fans either. I think a series of TV movies, or perhaps just one like the original, is the way to go, using the (new) Five O tie in as before with the original Five O tie in. Of course that's on CBS like the original MPI and I don't know what if any rights issue would come up with universal being under comcast/nbc now.

Post Reply