Just watched this episode, the end of season 4 after arriving home after jury duty. It was very enjoyable, but I didn't laugh as much as I should have? It did seem to have its comic appeal - definitely Higgins doing karate kicks should have done it, I guess I wasn't in the mood. I did smirk when rick (according to one of the guy's stories anyway) falls against the closet to get that broken nose!

I'll tell you one thing, I'd have never fired that piano lady with cleavage like that (and if you caught the quick shot with her in lingerie), I think I'd rather invite her in to be my personal caregiver/naked housecleaner! I love it when they put a babe in the episode!

Yes agreed about the piano lady! I think this is a great episode, very funny! One of the best of the "lighter" episodes. I thought of the three versions (Ricks, Higgins, and Tc's) of what happened Ricks was the best! When he acts like a tough guy he is hilarious. Although seeing Higgins karate action is damn good as well. I just came home from a terrible day when I watched this one and it definitely brightened my mood!

Anyone else spot the big flub throughout the episode?

Watching it again now I noticed it at the 5-6min mark when TM first get there and Higgins is talking. It's 2-3am in the morning, yet through the trellising behind Higgins it's broad daylight and what looks like the beach and the sea behind it.

(only went through the first 2 pages of this thread, sorry if it's already been mentioned)

Slightly overrated episode I think, though it grew on me on 2nd viewing. I thought they could've made more out of the multiple perspectives angle. Still quite good though.

Hehehehe..

To me the biggest laugh actually comes from Joy Kelly, who plays the singer, also called Joy. I especially love how she sings the song at the last round, when Higgins is telling his side of the story. The way she goes 'feeeelings, owowowowowow feeeelings!' makes me fall of the couch laughing every single time.

This ep is definitely one of my favorites!

Another flub related to the timing: Does it even make sense? Let's say Magnum's watching a baseball game at 2am in Hawaii ... That would make it something like 8am on the US east coast, an unusual time to be playing baseball. It seems like a surprising mistake given that the crew work/live in Hawaii for a good part of the year. They'd probably be familiar with the fact that mainland ball games would be on in the afternoon rather than late night.

Anyhow, I quite enjoyed the episode. The premise was a bit thin as people have pointed out, but amusing to see the guys acting out their images of themselves.

I seem to remember a line where Magnums says he avoided friends that day so they wouldn't reveal the score. I think he was simply watching a re-broadcast of a game which was played the day before.



Also, I thought this was interesting:
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/M ... homonStyle