Operation: Silent Night (4.10)

[IslandHopper]

LHG,

Yes, I had also noticed that the Ensign seemed to old, but I just figured that maybe he was previously an enlisted man who later went to Officer Candidate School (OCS). However, I think you are right, they should have had a younger man play that role to make it more believable.

The other quirky thing I noticed about the scene with the Captain and Ensign, is that the Captain is eating a catered dinner with wine in front of his sailors while they are busting their humps, on Christmas Eve, no less. This is not good leadership (bad for morale) and is not done.

_________________
The answer is obvious, old man. Logic is irrelevant. It's simply Tropical Madness. (J.Q. Higgins)

[golfmobile]

'Tis the season for watching this one!

So we watched this one last night, due to the current "season" and because Larry had never seen it (or couldn't remember ever seeing it).

First of all, I was horribly embarrassed for Rick. He was getting free transportation, and all he did was bitch and whine relentlessly! I wanted to slap him! He was NOT very likeable in this episode!

I thought it was cute when Rick and TM sneaked up on TC while he was singing and chimed in. I think this could have been "played" more as TC sang again later.

Also, from that scene, when they went running to try to flag down the Coast Guard chopper, Rick reasonably dropped his wood and went running for the beach. TM CARRIED his wood with him to the beach while running, then drops it on the beach. What was THAT all about? Looked sort of dumb.

Then Larry spotted this: While they were at the campfire that night, suddenly TM was wearing a camp/khaki shirt. He'd been in his tank-type tee shirt in all other scenes. Where did he get another shirt? Or did they all have luggage for an overnight stay wherever they were going? I wouldn't call this a "shocking flub," more a continuity issue, I think.

And on that note, TC was dropping them off then going back and going home to New Orleans. How were they going to get back to Oahu if TC was gone? If that were the case, wouldn't they all have gone to their destinations in the first place by local aircraft? Why would they have imposed on their good friend TC to fly them somewhere when he was trying to get home to the States? That seemed awfully selfish of them, at least to me it did.

Also, if you look closely, when they crash-land, you can see one of the struts break, or crack at least, right at the juncture with the fuselage (James, can you get a screenshot of this?). I would think this would be a major problem for lifting off again, with these pretty solid four guys in the aircraft. That isn't touched on. As for the frequency display lighted numerals on the radio, frankly, if the sun were shining on it at the right angle (and it appeared to be in the sunlight), you probably couldn't see a lighted display -- you'd have to shade it with your hand to see the numbers anyway. So I think they can get away with not showing any display in this circumstance.

And on what little island did they crash? I Google-Earthed it to check my thoughts, and there's nothing between Oahu and Molokai

Also, I'm not the expert in this area -- I'm sure someone else here can help me with this, but for the idea of the crash itself, why wouldn't TC have cut power and done an autorotation, over which he would have pretty good control, if he's as good a heli pilot as he is indicated as being, instead of trying to come in and land with the power still running and being compromised by the ineffective tail rotor? Helicopter experts here, does this make sense?

Don't mean to pick on the episode since what I'm picking on is the basis for the entire scenario of the episode. And I did love TM's coming up with a little Christmas tree (correctly a Cook pine, usually called a Norfolk Island pine, which is really isn't, it's a Cook -- and these trees are prolific all over the Hawaiian islands), but where did he get the silver/aluminum star he put on top of it?

I just wish in eight years the show had done more Christmas shows, even if Hawaii doesn't really have the weather for it, as discussed by TM in the introductory narrative to this episode.

And with Higgins trying to use the Japanese airplane as a boat -- that sure reminded me anachronistically of "Six Days, Seven Nights," where the floats on the plane in that movie DID work. But then Harrison Ford was doing the "construction," not JQH!

Then their lifiting off just as the bombing starts -- after working all day on the heli, suddenly after dark, TC gets it conveniently fixed? This episode across the board was just a little TOO contrived for me, just one of them that was "trying too hard." Sorry, guys!

Now don't shoot me, this is all just my opinion.

golf

_________________
"Portside, buddy."

[J.J. Walters]

[Frodoleader]

This episode has become a Christmas tradition for my family. We watched it again on Christmas Eve.
Is it just me, or has anyone noticed that the bridge or command center on the Navy ship, does not look like any type of naval vessel at all. In fact it looks more like a poorly prepared set, complete with curtains. Although I never was in the Navy, did they use curtains on their ships? Were they color coordinated with the carpeting?
Also, I agree about the captain eating & drinking wine in front of his crew.

[golfmobile]

Just found this on another site. If this is correct, then this should be a "shocking flub"?

[rubber chicken]

I found the location of the beach shots. The place is Puaena Point, the northern tip of Waialua Bay, on the north shore of Oahu. Here's where Higgins write his will and talks to TC. And here's where they launch Higgins' doomed "sailing" craft.



Some more info: In the interview Sam posted, of David Romas interviewing Roger Mosley, Mosley mentions Operation: Silent Night stands out as one of his favorites.

[Magnums Little Voice]

This episode was superb, the story was great, I loved Higgin's attempt to build the boat, and it was hilarious when it sank!!

A real classic Magnum this one!

[IKnowWhatYoureThinking]

1) There is no alcohol on naval vessels.
2) The captian would've been in the wardroom or his stateroom.
3) An Ensign would not have been clearing the captians plate.
4) That ship had too much open space and glass. A real navy ship is much more closed quarters.

[A P Leyland]

Love this episode. It's my favourite next to LIMBO. Yes, it's contrived and it really doesn't need the 'Jeapordy' plotline but as a character study it's brilliant.

The Higgins/TC relationship is great in this episode (I always liked the TC/Higgins stuff - they seem to have a lot of respect for each other), the comedy is genuinely funny and it's just such a fun episode. My kids all liked this one as well so there's a vote of confidence for you.

Andy

[IKnowWhatYoureThinking]

Didn't Manetti say somewhere that this was his favorite episode?