All For One (2) (5.16)

Rate, review & discuss the episodes from the fifth season

Moderator: Styles Bitchley

How Would You Rate This Episode?

10 (Perfect!)
7
9%
9.5 (One of the Best)
9
12%
9.0 (Excellent)
19
25%
8.5 (Very Good)
9
12%
8.0 (Pretty Good)
14
19%
7.5 (Decent)
10
13%
7.0 (Average at Best)
2
3%
6.5 (Not So Good)
2
3%
6.0 (Pretty Bad)
1
1%
5.0 (Just Awful)
2
3%
 
Total votes: 75

Message
Author
RamblerReb
Commander
Posts: 48
Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2011 12:24 pm

#11 Post by RamblerReb »

MaiTaiMan wrote:
RamblerReb wrote: Now a little niggle I had with this episode: How is it that Rick brought his Detonics with him, but Magnum left his 1911 at home? Surely if Rick could get his piece in-country, Magnum should have been able to. It's not important, but it bothered me.
Just a little show-quirk you're just supposed to go with. :wink: Sometimes if you get too "technical" or try to analyze every aspect to each episode...you'll find things don't always match reality. Sometimes you just have to watch the episode and go with it...you'll enjoy it a lot more. :)
I understand that, but I, as you may have noted, am a technical kind of guy. I still enjoy Magnum, don't worry. I wouldn't have four seasons of it if I didn't! :)

User avatar
MaiTaiMan
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 419
Joined: Mon May 16, 2011 12:43 am
Location: Mid-West

#12 Post by MaiTaiMan »

RamblerReb wrote:
MaiTaiMan wrote:
RamblerReb wrote: Now a little niggle I had with this episode: How is it that Rick brought his Detonics with him, but Magnum left his 1911 at home? Surely if Rick could get his piece in-country, Magnum should have been able to. It's not important, but it bothered me.
Just a little show-quirk you're just supposed to go with. :wink: Sometimes if you get too "technical" or try to analyze every aspect to each episode...you'll find things don't always match reality. Sometimes you just have to watch the episode and go with it...you'll enjoy it a lot more. :)
I understand that, but I, as you may have noted, am a technical kind of guy. I still enjoy Magnum, don't worry. I wouldn't have four seasons of it if I didn't! :)
LOL! :lol: I have noticed you are a very technical guy (walking encyclopedia)--have learned a lot and find some of it very interesting.

But even though I like some "technicality", after a while it gets old for me, and it sort of ruins the "point" to episodes/shows. That's just me, though. 8)

But...you have only 4 seasons?? Why not all 8? :)
"It was more ironic than a Robin Masters novel--she thought he was dead, he thought she was dead...and only the chauffeur knew the truth! He should have been the butler!" "Lest We Forget"

User avatar
miltontheripper
Vice Admiral
Posts: 108
Joined: Sun Feb 06, 2011 9:48 pm
Location: Michigan

#13 Post by miltontheripper »

I am posting this for both of the two part episodes. Wow this was a great two parter! Even though he's pretty much a complete schmuck Tyler P Mickenny is a GREAT character in my opinion, out of sight lol! Seeing all the guys pool together for the same mission was awesome. Loved the action in this episode, especially Higgins with a machine gun. Definitely one of the highlights of season 5 in my opinion. Rated it a 9.0

User avatar
mandolabar
Captain
Posts: 60
Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2011 1:28 am

#14 Post by mandolabar »

I watched this last night with my daughter...we liked it, the way it contrasted their "at home" level of sparring, which can seem very serious, with their support and care for each other when it really counts.

I loved the interaction, and how it showed how each of them really understood the others. Best line was Higgins': I'll go next, after he and Magnum heard the torturers bringing McKinney back. Knowing quite well what he faced and willing to put himself before those he cared about.

~Amanda

User avatar
robspace54
Vice Admiral
Posts: 143
Joined: Thu Nov 12, 2009 7:18 pm
Location: Cincinnati, Ohio

#15 Post by robspace54 »

Watched both parts the other day. The last time I saw it was in Feb. 1985 when on vacation in Maui. We were staying in Lahaina and remember getting ready for dinner with the TV on and it all fit with Magnum on the tube. The crescent moon was shining over the palm trees, and my pregnant wife was wearing a fetching outfit. That in utero baby girl is now a married woman and is 26 years old... How time flies.

Hard to think now what a long shadow the Vietnam War cast over that era, and Magnum, p.i. , a tv show, dealt very well with it.
Sometimes I get so lucky, even I don`t believe it.

Croix de Lorraine
Admiral
Posts: 195
Joined: Sun Jul 31, 2011 6:49 pm

#16 Post by Croix de Lorraine »

I like the ending. The irony of Rick killing the girl's father, the apparently selfish Tyler sacrificing himself for those children and finally the sweet rest of the warriors.

SignGuyHPW
Admiral
Posts: 191
Joined: Sun Apr 13, 2014 5:58 pm

Re: All For One (2) (5.16)

#17 Post by SignGuyHPW »

Good episode even though it seemed to move kind of slow in the begining.

I'm not sure how the major was able to shake off being blown up like it was nothing. He must have been really, really tough. I thought the part with Rick falling in love and wanting to marry the girl was a bit much. They'd done it so much with him that I think it lost a little of the impact here. Instead of thinking, "wow, he must not be thinking clearly about this. He's only known her a few hours and most of those he was delerious" I thought, "oh, this again."

The parts where TC and Joe interacted were really great. TC running out to get the kid's body in hopes that he may be alive despite the heavy fire around him was a pretty dramatic scene. The guys being helpless as the woman was shot above them was also pretty dramatic. Once it was wrapped up and they went back to their normal lives it was a great metaphor for what happens in war.

User avatar
ENSHealy
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 639
Joined: Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: All For One (2) (5.16)

#18 Post by ENSHealy »

EPISODE: All For One (Part Two)

Famous guest stars:
Image
Hawaiian shirts: 1
Tigers Cap:
Image
Island Hopper shirts: 1
Shirtless Magnum:
OMG:
Higgins Organizations:
Higgins musings:
Negotiations:
Body Count: 1 – Only counting Major Thieu, not all the extras
Bullet wounds:
Little Voice:
I know what you’re thinking:
When I write HTBAWCPI:
Investigator corrections:
4th wall breaks:
Magnumometer: 3
Magnumometer Moments: https://vimeo.com/566759476
Ensign Healy
Scholar in Residence
The Institute for Advanced Magnum Studies

"I woke up one day at 53 and realized I'd never been 23."

Blackmamba
Lieutenant
Posts: 23
Joined: Wed Jan 12, 2022 1:46 pm

Re: All For One (2) (5.16)

#19 Post by Blackmamba »

My favorite moment? Higgins driving up in that truck with a stogie in his mouth! Very believable.

User avatar
charybdis1966
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 285
Joined: Thu Feb 04, 2010 11:56 am
Location: Buckinghamshire, England
Contact:

Re: All For One (2) (5.16)

#20 Post by charybdis1966 »

This story had so many A Team overtones - did they just lift some incidental music from that programme onto MPI as it was just TC instead of BA Baracus ? I believe the Post/Carpenter team worked on both series.

That gripe aside this was a counterbalance to the proliferation of light-hearted “fluff” episodes in season 5.

The darkest scene was TM’s monologue while McKinney’s shrieks from being tortured were heard occasionally.
Higgins showed he was a courageous man when he said he’d go next after McKinney was brought back, a bloodied and bruised mess.

The final scene back at the estate did bring into sharp relief how the war never really left TM, TC and Rick.

Despite some cheesy interludes this one made me think.

User avatar
Luther's nephew Dobie
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 1248
Joined: Thu May 30, 2013 4:16 am
Location: Swamps of Jersey

Re: All For One (2) (5.16)

#21 Post by Luther's nephew Dobie »

charybdis1966 wrote: Mon May 16, 2022 12:42 am This story had so many A Team overtones - did they just lift some incidental music from that programme onto MPI as it was just TC instead of BA Baracus ? I believe the Post/Carpenter team worked on both series.

That gripe aside this was a counterbalance to the proliferation of light-hearted “fluff” episodes in season 5.
The darkest scene was TM’s monologue while McKinney’s shrieks from being tortured were heard occasionally.
Higgins showed he was a courageous man when he said he’d go next after McKinney was brought back, a bloodied and bruised mess.
The final scene back at the estate did bring into sharp relief how the war never really left TM, TC and Rick.
Despite some cheesy interludes this one made me think.
It struck that while this 2 parter is a prominent episode teeming with subtext which give a searing insight into who Magnum and the boys are,
there have been a grand total of 20 comments since 2007 while some inferior episodes have reams of replies.

User avatar
charybdis1966
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 285
Joined: Thu Feb 04, 2010 11:56 am
Location: Buckinghamshire, England
Contact:

Re: All For One (2) (5.16)

#22 Post by charybdis1966 »

Luther's nephew Dobie wrote: Mon May 16, 2022 2:52 am
It struck that while this 2 parter is a prominent episode teeming with subtext which give a searing insight into who Magnum and the boys are,
there have been a grand total of 20 comments since 2007 while some inferior episodes have reams of replies.
Yes, that occurred to me too; the only thing I can think of to rationalise this is maybe a lot of people have commented on the Part 1 thread for the whole two parter instead.

User avatar
Luther's nephew Dobie
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 1248
Joined: Thu May 30, 2013 4:16 am
Location: Swamps of Jersey

Re: All For One (2) (5.16)

#23 Post by Luther's nephew Dobie »

charybdis1966 wrote: Mon May 16, 2022 11:20 am
Luther's nephew Dobie wrote: Mon May 16, 2022 2:52 am
It struck that while this 2 parter is a prominent episode teeming with subtext which give a searing insight into who Magnum and the boys are,
there have been a grand total of 20 comments since 2007 while some inferior episodes have reams of replies.
Yes, that occurred to me too; the only thing I can think of to rationalise this is maybe a lot of people have commented on the Part 1 thread for the whole two parter instead.
Hi Charybdis1966,
You are right of course, I came across All For One (5.16) without thinking to check the comments for the first part, 5.15.
Color me red for I was one of many posting there about this excellent 2 parter, but once you get over 900 comments on the MM boards you forget what you posted.
The most chilling moment we discussed there was when Higgins reluctantly translated to Magnum what the Thai hooker said to and about Rick, that she was looking into the eyes of a dead man.
What a stone, soulless bitch and what good writing. How many other series would have included such a moment?

User avatar
charybdis1966
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 285
Joined: Thu Feb 04, 2010 11:56 am
Location: Buckinghamshire, England
Contact:

Re: All For One (2) (5.16)

#24 Post by charybdis1966 »

Luther's nephew Dobie wrote: Mon May 16, 2022 4:54 pm
Hi Charybdis1966,
You are right of course, I came across All For One (5.16) without thinking to check the comments for the first part, 5.15.
Color me red for I was one of many posting there about this excellent 2 parter, but once you get over 900 comments on the MM boards you forget what you posted.
The most chilling moment we discussed there was when Higgins reluctantly translated to Magnum what the Thai hooker said to and about Rick, that she was looking into the eyes of a dead man.
What a stone, soulless bitch and what good writing. How many other series would have included such a moment?
[/quote]

You’re so right about forgetting what you’ve posted. I’m only in the 200 and something number of posts and I have several times in the last few months watched an episode for what I think is the first time and then looked at the relevant thread and found a comment from myself from about 9 years ago saying how much I liked or disliked it.
The trouble is my opinions back then don’t even always agree with what I think now !
It feels like I’m contradicting myself when that happens. 😬

Treadwell
Lieutenant Commander
Posts: 34
Joined: Thu May 26, 2022 6:46 am

Re: All For One (2) (5.16)

#25 Post by Treadwell »

Funny how editing works out: Part 1 apparently came up short, hence the extended teaser and end credits.

THIS one probably has the shortest end credits of the series! ;)

Post Reply