Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

For all non-episode specific topics about the show, including MPI-related "tie-ins"

Moderator: Styles Bitchley

Message
Author
User avatar
Stelth
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 369
Joined: Sat Apr 20, 2013 9:31 pm
Location: Ft. Liquordale, FL

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#31 Post by Stelth »

Great first post & welcome. :magnum:

User avatar
Doc Ibold
Maniac Emeritus
Posts: 1741
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2007 8:16 pm
Location: Detroit

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#32 Post by Doc Ibold »

Welcome aboard! (Nice post too)

User avatar
Danno
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 507
Joined: Sat Feb 10, 2007 11:03 pm
Location: Edge Of The Pacific, Sydney, Australia

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#33 Post by Danno »

Snazster, I like this.

I did notice that Robin Masters can anagram to: As one Brit RSM (RSM being the abbreviation of Regimental Sergeant Major) but I think I may be clutching at straws. :wink:
Help protect Hawaiʻi's Green Sea Turtles http://malamanahonu.org

mikeaz123
Commander
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri Apr 18, 2008 5:33 am

Re:

#34 Post by mikeaz123 »

Majordomo wrote:My feeling is that Higgins is not Robin...pretty much for many of the reasons already cited. I do like the inference that Magnum makes saying Robin sound like Orson Wells, lol.

I saw on imdb that Orson Welles was supposed to appear as Robin in the later seasons but died before that could happen. That would have been a cool episode!

User avatar
mctyler
Lieutenant Junior Grade
Posts: 6
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 4:47 pm
Location: italy

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#35 Post by mctyler »

I've read every post but I would like to think over these questions:

-Why is Magnum invited for free to dependance by a man he never knows?
-Why does Higgins call "my ferrari","my house","my mail" etc in many episodes?..Magnum considers this one also as a proof that Higgins=Robin M
-Why does Higgins get angry and fear so much when Magnum read his written texts?
-Why Higgins avoids Magnum to send away home at the end of many episodes?..Higgins always invents an excuse as make an inventory and so on..

Well..I think that exists a sureness,that is Higgins knows who Robin Masters is,as it seems he wants to tell him in the room of hospital,when Magnum was in coma...
he could be Higgins,though ,as you have written, there is a proof that is another one in "italian ice".
I think that if not Higgins there is a new pretender...the grandfather of Magnum..(resolutions S 8 ).It's possible that the hidden benefactor is a relative..he has wanted to protect Magnum from afar,He has always had an adventurous life ,so is not impossible that he is a writer also..everything is explained,you think this! :lol:
It 's still early, but I think I'll go home and have a drink, so somewhere in the world the sun is about sinking JQHiggins

User avatar
The Birdman
Vice Admiral
Posts: 140
Joined: Sat Mar 13, 2010 6:08 am
Location: Rainy Oregon.

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#36 Post by The Birdman »

mctyler wrote:I've read every post but I would like to think over these questions:

-Why is Magnum invited for free to dependance by a man he never knows?-Why does Higgins call "my ferrari","my house","my mail" etc in many episodes?..Magnum considers this one also as a proof that Higgins=Robin M
-Why does Higgins get angry and fear so much when Magnum read his written texts?
-Why Higgins avoids Magnum to send away home at the end of many episodes?..Higgins always invents an excuse as make an inventory and so on..

Well..I think that exists a sureness,that is Higgins knows who Robin Masters is,as it seems he wants to tell him in the room of hospital,when Magnum was in coma...
he could be Higgins,though ,as you have written, there is a proof that is another one in "italian ice".
I think that if not Higgins there is a new pretender...the grandfather of Magnum..(resolutions S 8 ).It's possible that the hidden benefactor is a relative..he has wanted to protect Magnum from afar,He has always had an adventurous life ,so is not impossible that he is a writer also..everything is explained,you think this! :lol:
(as far as I know and I'm no expert) Magnum was HIRED to be "head of security" for Robim Masters and gets room and bourd with the deal. Magnum also works his other cases on the side for extra money.
Uh PHRASING!!!!

User avatar
Higgy_baby
Rear Admiral
Posts: 87
Joined: Wed Jul 15, 2009 11:38 pm
Location: Canada

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#37 Post by Higgy_baby »

I'd like to think there is a Robin, but why in all the years has he never shown up at the 'Estate', and if not revealing himself publicly at least connecting with his two must trusted confidentes ?
Of course this changes nothing between us. I still expect you to respect the rules and regulations pertaining to your stay on the estate. There will be no wild parties, no outragous liberties, no unauthorized overnight guests...

sqlz
Ensign
Posts: 2
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2013 11:28 am

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#38 Post by sqlz »

My theory is that Magnum's father is Robin Masters. His death was faked for covert operations during the war and he always meant to come back afterwards but his alternate life proved too tempting. He provides the free board and use of the Ferrari because of a guilty conscience.

He (Robin Masters) is also Higgins half-brother (the one that got his looks from his mother).

User avatar
J.J. Walters
Founding Father
Posts: 4196
Joined: Tue Jan 02, 2007 10:54 pm
Location: Suburbia, USA
Contact:

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#39 Post by J.J. Walters »

Higgy_baby wrote:I'd like to think there is a Robin, but why in all the years has he never shown up at the 'Estate', and if not revealing himself publicly at least connecting with his two must trusted confidentes ?
He did, twice: in "J. Digger Doyle" and "The Big Blow". ;)
Higgins: It's not a scratch! It's a bloody gouge!

User avatar
308GUY
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 1228
Joined: Fri Mar 08, 2013 11:42 pm
Location: OH,USA

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#40 Post by 308GUY »

sqlz wrote:He (Robin Masters) is also Higgins half-brother (the one that got his looks from his mother).
LOL :lol: That's funny right there!

Interesting take on the situation and I suppose all the details could probably be explained away, either realistically or by ignoring reality, but it does leave allot to be explained. After Elmo and Fr Paddy, one starts to wonder just how many "half brothers" ole' Higgy baby actually had! :magnum:

Either way...welcome to the forum, hope you enjoy your stay, you won't find a better bunch of folks anywhere on the net...or a site with even half the info about Magnum PI and anything/everything associated with it!

:magnum:
"C'mon TC...nothing can go wrong!"

User avatar
Reef monkey
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 222
Joined: Thu May 24, 2012 3:30 pm
Location: Houston, Tx

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#41 Post by Reef monkey »

I vote no, too much evidence, especially early on, for them being two different people.

Though the idea of Robin being a guy Higgins partnered with while Higgins does all the writing is compelling, the J. Digger Doyle Episode, with Robin driving around in the Rolls Royce in the South of France, and then Higgins talking to him on the phone, calling him "Mr. Masters", all without Magnum or anyone else except us the viewer being present to witness, seems to be an expensive and unnecessary level of effort to go to in order to keep up the charade.

I think if anything, Higgins is charged with keeping RM's privacy, and when he sees Magnum wondering if he might be, he takes advantage of that by protecting his privacy by making people think he doesn't even exist, and he does that with Magnum by denying it, in a very cryptic way that makes the denial not quite seem genuine - reverse psychology. Plus, I think Higgins just enjoys yanking Magnum's chain.
My essay "In Country: Place and Historical Connection in Magnum PI", about the importance of the Honolulu/Vietnam connection in the show:
http://magnum-mania.com/Forum/viewtopic ... 850#p57850

User avatar
Higgins (aka Bondtoys)
Fleet Admiral
Posts: 607
Joined: Fri Dec 11, 2009 2:04 pm

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#42 Post by Higgins (aka Bondtoys) »

SQUEEZE PLAY is imo the best evidence that Higgins is NOT Robin Masters.

Benoit knows Robin for so many years personally - even if Higgins was using an actor - why should he put the estate on jeopardy for the silly softball match. And Higgin's embarrasement that he depends on Magnum and his team is not staged - if it was he must be a really decadent and bored millionaire

SignGuyHPW
Admiral
Posts: 191
Joined: Sun Apr 13, 2014 5:58 pm

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#43 Post by SignGuyHPW »

THIS always bothered me. It was well established, in my view, that Higgins and Robin Masters were not the same person. Some of the things that established it: It was inferred in the pilot that Magnum had known Robin Mastesr and was then hired by him to head security at his Hawaiian estate, there were multiple episodes where Robin, Higgins, and Magnum interacted, Magnum would occassionally reference having seen or talked to Robin recently, Higgins would reference that he'd have to resign or could be let go by Mr. Masters, Higgins seemingly didn't know Magnum when he was hired as security implying he'd not have known and hired him previously, Higgins was working on his memoires and that was used as a recurring comedy bit which would imply Higgins was not an accomplished writer, Higgins replaced a former mayordomo which would imply he didn't own the estate for years after it became Robin Master's property.

To shoot down some of the theories that would support it: Higgins hiring an actor to portray Robin Masters would make the plots of the episodes featuring Robin not make sense due to the actor not interacting with anyone influential enough for it to matter, if Higgins became successful after a novel or two then why wouldn't he just use a fictional name and launch his own brand, why would it matter to Higgins that Robin Masters be living a playboy lifestyle 24/7 when he could just pay occassional trips when the media would be covering things it'd be expected to see a famous writer, why wouldn't Higgins hire a staff to do all of the chores that seem to fall into his job description if he's already paying a guy to live a celebrity lifestyle for him

I always felt that after Orson Wells passed away the writers decided to write off Robin with this storyline. The passing was sudden and they couldn't do the planned episodes with Orson actually appearing completely so they figured they could make Higgins into Robin and combine the two characters rather than completely change actors and introduce a new Robin.

I thought it'd have been better to do an episode where they get news that Robin suddenly passed away and he had it in his will that Higgins would get everything associated with the Hawaii estate. That way you could get Magnum investigating the death to see if it was accidental or murder, you could get comedy out of Higgins suddenly coming into wealth and being the owner of everything he was in charge of for so long, you could tie up the show by having Higgins deciding he would rather work for what he has rather than being given it and sell the estate.

User avatar
Kwai Bridge
Captain
Posts: 57
Joined: Sun Aug 03, 2014 12:44 pm

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#44 Post by Kwai Bridge »

Today I've come across "The Look" episode again, and it led me to some interesting thoughts while watching it...haven't seen anyone mention anything nearly similar in the dedicated episode thread, so I guess I actually have something to contribute with. I believe it's not bad for a second post and I hope someone responds! I wrote the basic concept for it in less than 5 minutes, but it took me over an hour to make a final version. Anyway, here we go. :wink:

If we take into consideration Magnum's theory that Higgins is Robin Masters, and that he has all the resources, while hiring some random guy to pose as Robin Masters, it would make no sense for Higgins (who is Robin in this case) to phone the guy who's posing as Robin to phone Magnum to construct Higgins (Robin) himself a birthday present, while missing the date entirely! If it was Higgins' doing all along, you would guess that he would tell Magnum the correct date of his own birthday!

That would either mean:
  • That Higgins did it on purpose, for some unknown reason
  • That the guy who's posing as Robin told Magnum to build the castle for Higgins on his own call and gave him the resources to keep Magnum thinking he is the real Robin, and that he simply forgot the date, but then it contradicts the theory that Higgins pulls all the strings and has all the resources
  • That the guy who's posing as Robin actually IS Robin and he simply forgot the date
Higgins himself in this very episode said: "Mr. Masters is frightfully absent-minded about dates." If Higgins isn't Robin then it would makes perfect sense. But if he is, that would mean he's simply lying, since we all know Higgins remembers his entire history by dates, and that he threw himself a fake birthday party for some unknown, selfish reason.

Beside this and other small confusing things, Magnum's theory would work perfectly. In "Resolutions" he even asked Higgins why does he call a guy posing as Robin "Mr. Masters" even when two of them are alone, to which Higgins gave him an explanation, but then at the end of the episode he said that he lied about being Robin. Apparently Higgins likes to lie, but we never know if he's actually lying or not. Ugh, my head hurts so MUCH!

Another thing that boggles my mind is how no one of the invited Higgins' friends didn't know that Higgins actually didn't have a birthday on that date.

Anyway, thoughts, anyone?

User avatar
EZiller
Captain
Posts: 61
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2014 9:28 pm
Location: East of the Sandwich Islands

Re: Is Jonathan Higgins Robin Masters?

#45 Post by EZiller »

Here's one theory:

Yes and no. Higgins and RM are definitely two separate people and RM’s series of lurid pulp fiction are a collaborative effort of work between them. The person who became the famous celebrity writer was actually Elmer Masterman. Elmer was a British war correspondent in WW2. As a youth he had read hundreds of books about the great military heroes of the Empire, as had JQ Higgins. However, his diminutive size and health problems would prohibit him from serving in any sort of combat role, so he became a correspondent, figuring that to be the closest way to get to the action. He first met Higgins in the N Africa campaign. They were of the same age, grew up not too far from one another and while many of the British officers Masterman came into contact with would ridicule his appearance, Sgt. Major Higgins always treated him with respect and also had a much better knowledge of what was actually happening during the campaigns. Masterman wasn’t a great writer, but he was an excellent listener and he enjoyed nothing better than sharing a bottle of brandy or Scotch with Higgins and listen to him relate what had happened on the front or the strategy involved. Higgins knew he could trust Masterman and over the years, they would quite often run into each other, whether it was the Middle East, India or SE Asia and Higgins would share his tales of adventure and intrigue.

Masterman had been trying to get his novels published, but had nothing but a drawer of rejection letters from various publishing houses for his efforts. One evening in Singapore, after long night of imbibing and listening to his frustrations, Higgins offered to read his latest manuscript and see if he may offer some creative editorial assistance. Higgy had a lot of fun with it-he had become a fan of the Ian Fleming’s Bond novels and Higgy punched up the work with plenty of sex and violence, retitled it “Babes in Babylon” and also suggested that Elmer Masterman use a pen name and came up with the alias of Robin Masters. Robin loved the idea and the finished project-he offered to share co-writing credits with Higgins, who absolutely wanted no part of formally being associated with such trash. [Besides, he never thought it actually would be published] Lo and behold, “Babes” was published, would be made into a movie and the public clamored for more RM novels. Robin and Higgins were now in a bit of a dilemma, since Higgins had totally rewritten Robin’s dull work. Higgins didn’t want to see his friends work discredited and Robin Masters, while an average writer, did prove to be a genius at self- promotion. So, a collaborative union was born. Higgins was getting close to retirement and splitting the royalties from the novels was a windfall for a man who was expecting to live on a modest soldiers pension after retirement. Together they came up with an elaborate ruse. Robin bought an elaborate estate in Hawaii and would install Higgins as the caretaker, who would have plenty of free time in paradise to continue to edit and rewrite Robin’s novels. Of course this would be unknown to everyone but the two of them. Higgins, besides rewriting RM’s work could also begin working on his memoirs, a journal of his 30 years in the British army and intelligence service, which he was sure would outsell any of the RM pulp he had put together, while RM traveled the world and became the darling of the literary and movie industry. Higgins was content to live as the country gentleman in paradise.

This was until RM brought to estate one Thomas Sullivan Magnum, a recently retired USN officer whom he had originally met in SE Asia after the fall of Saigon. And that is another story.

Post Reply